IPng Area Status Report Scott Bradner < sob@harvard.edu> Allison Mankin IETF 29 Seattle WA March 28 1994 Review ¥ started Sep 1993 ¥ directorate formed ¥ working groups formed ¥ requirements process underway ¥ white papers solicited ¥ external review panel selected Directorate J. Allard - Microsoft Steve Bellovin - AT&T Jim Bound - Digital Ross Callon - Wellfleet Brian Carpenter - CERN Dave Clark - MIT (EXRP chair) John Curran - NEARnet Steve Deering - Xerox Dino Farinacci - Cisco Paul Francis - NTT Eric Fleischmann - Boeing Daniel Karrenberg - RARE Mark Knopper - Ameritech Greg Minshall - Novell Paul Mockapetris - ISI Rob Ullmann - Lotus Lixia Zhang - Xerox IESG & IAB selection impact on directorate ¥ rule at start no IESG or IAB on directorate ¥ 3 directorate members selected by nomcom Paul Mockapetris - IESG chair Brian Carpenter - IAB Lixia Zhang - IAB ¥ plan Paul Mockapetris will withdraw from directorate too busy & potential conflict Brian Carpenter & Lixia Zhang will stay well into IPng process, only a few months left both contribute much to directorate deliberations IAB not part of approval procedure IPng archive ¥ hsdndev.harvard.edu (pub/ipng) directorate mailing list archive white papers Working Groups ¥ proposals sipp Steve Deering, Paul Francis and Bob Hinden tuba Peter Ford and Mark Knopper catnip Vladimir Sukonnik Working Groups ¥ other IPng working groups ale Frank Solensky and Tony Li ngreq Frank Kastenholz and Jon Crowcroft tacit Geoff Huston and Atul Bansal White Papers ¥ proposal overviews ¥ RFC 1550 solicit requirements for IPng ¥ reviewed by directorate for clarity ¥ most now internet-drafts some waiting for author revisions ¥ will become Informational RFCs part of IPng record Proposal White Papers Peter Ford and Mark Knopper TUBA as IPng: A White Paper Bob Hinden Simple Internet Protocol Plus White Paper Michael McGovern and Robert Ullman CATNIP: Common Architecture for the Internet Requirements White Papers ¥ Steve Bellovin - AT&T On Many Addresses Per Host ¥ Steve Bellovin - AT&T Security Concerns for IPng ¥ Jim Bound - Digital IPng Host Implementation Analysis ¥ Chris Brazdziunas - Bellcore IPng Support for ATM Services ¥ Brian Carpenter - CERN IPng White Paper on Transition Plus Other Considerations ¥ Russ Clark et al- Georgia Tech Multiprotocol Interoperability in IPng ¥ John Curran Market Viability as an IPng Criteria Requirements White Papers - contd. ¥ Eric Fleischman - Boeing Computer Services A User's View of IPng ¥ A. Ghiselli et al - INFN-CNAF Untitled ¥ Dan Green et al - NSWC-DD HPN Working Group Input to IPng Requirements Solicitation ¥ Denise Heagerty - CERN Input to IPng Engineering Considerations ¥ Ron Skelton - EPRI Electric Power Research Institute Response to RFC 1550 Requirements White Papers - contd. ¥ S. Symington et al - DMSO Modeling and Simulation Requirements for IPng ¥ John Tavs - IBM IPng White Paper ¥ Mario Vecchi - Time-Warner Cable IPng Requirements: A Cable Television Industry Viewpoint IPng Schedule ¥ now draft requirements document done requirements BOF here draft requirements doc to review panel ¥ April final requirements doc request paper from proponents ¥ May proponents response directorate review IPng Schedule - contd. ¥ June draft recommendation from ADs to directorate sent to review panel ¥ July final recommendation from ADs presented in Toronto forwarded to IESG ¥ August last call issued ¥ September (?) IESG decision Possible Outcomes ¥ none - IPv4 can do the job ¥ one of above as-is tweaked heavy tweaked ¥ none of the above - 'do this' Politics ¥ pressure for convergence with ISO ¥ have to understand even if dismiss as not a technical requirement ¥ may address in recommendation will not effect recommendation IPng schedule for week ¥ Monday 1330-1530 Address Extension by IP Option Usage BOF (aeiou) ¥ Monday 1600-1800 Address Lifetime Expectations WG (ale) ¥ Tuesday 930-1200 TCP/UDP over CLNP-addressed Networks WG (tuba) ¥ Tuesday 1300-1530 Common Architecture for Next-Generation IP WG (catnip) ¥ Tuesday 1600-1800 TCP/UDP over CLNP-addressed Networks WG (tuba) ¥ Wednesday 930-1200 Transition and Coexistence Including Testing BOF (tacit) ¥ Wednesday 1330-1530 Simple Internet Protocol Plus WG (sipp) IPng schedule for week - contd. ¥ Thursday 930-1200 IPNG Requirements BOF (ngreqs) ¥ Thursday 1330-1530 Simple Internet Protocol Plus WG (sipp) ¥ Friday 900-1200 Open IPNG Directorate Meeting (ngdir) ¥ many other sessions relevant Schedule this am ¥ IPng status - us ¥ ALE report - Frank Solensky & Tony Li ¥ TACIT intro - Geoff Huston ¥ IPREQ report - Jon Crowcroft ¥ EXRP intro - Dave Clark